 |
Just for fun we'd like to know which of the modern versions of Sherlock Holmes do you prefer and if you like tell us why? |
|
 |
|
| CBS Elementary |
  
10.40% (36) |
|
| BBC Sherlock |
|
89.60% (310) |
|
|
|
| Total comments added = 13 |
Total votes cast = 346 |
| |
| [ Add Comment |
Vote Now | Other Polls ] |
|
|
|
Comment made by Jim (174.30.153.111 ) on 2013-05-13 12:18:12
|
| Although Johnny Lee Miller is British, the entire concept of this show is unlike one that a person is used to. I think what gets me the most is that there is a female Dr. Watson just doesn't follow the pattern one is used to. I agree that it is a good show and that it is well acted, but just isn't the same. I assume you are asking about the Sherlock with Benedict Cumberbatch. This young man has been in a lot of different shows over the past few years and pulls off the Sherlock character very well. I still have a small problem with Sherlock being in the 21st century in both series. Out of all, however, I think your Sherlock is the best. It is the most realistic of all. |
|
|
Comment made by Kurt from MN (74.36.144.124 ) on 2013-05-11 16:41:16
|
| Ok, now I know the poll was about TV shows. Haven't seen them. I was referring to the much preferred radio dramas. KE |
|
|
Comment made by Kurt from Minnesota (74.36.144.124 ) on 2013-05-11 16:36:18
|
| I don't know what the difference between the 2 choices are. But, is it that some of the stories hold my attention because they are interesting, while others spend a whole bunch of time just yakking along and bore me so much I totally drift away? I either REALLY like the stories, or REALLY don't. The "Lion's Mane" is an example of a GREAT story. Keep up the great work though, the programming you provide is unique and greatly appreciated. Sincerely, KE |
|
|
Comment made by B. May (24.173.155.58 ) on 2013-04-11 20:55:03
|
| I was a bit disappointed when I found out that CBS was going to spin their tale with a female Watson so I may have been jaded from the start. But, after watching it I found it to be very entertaining, as a detective show. If you go in to it looking at it this way you will also find it easy to watch.
The BBC has done such a fabulous job with sticking to the canon in so many slick ways. The casual fan will miss a great many of the references that the writers are very keen to include.
As Larry mentioned, I will continue to watch and enjoy both of the programs but "Sherlock" is by far the better modern day Sherlock Holmes show.
Let's hope both Benedict and Martin can both find time to continue making these great programs!
ps,..... What's up with the three episodes per season BBC???
B. May |
|
|
Comment made by PCSinWV (173.81.142.53 ) on 2013-04-04 17:48:34
|
| The Brits have always made the best Holmes presentations. |
|
|
Comment made by Kent Padilla (68.44.130.32 ) on 2013-01-10 11:42:12
|
| I definitely like the BBC version because it's more about thinking: you see how and why he arrives to his conclusion, usually in a very calculating and fast way. It does get slow though. I've seen all six episodes of the BBC version and am up to date with the CBS version. CBS' version is more humorous and built to the casual stereotypical American viewer. I actually like Jonny Lee Miller's take on SH, because he's really a sad, bored guy. Benedict Cumberbatch is on the cheery side. (I wouldn't trade that scene where they're laughing on the sofa in Buckingham Palace for the world though, it's perfect.) It's like watching college American football and NFL American football. You might prefer one, but they're both good. |
|
|
Comment made by Mark (199.30.220.46 ) on 2012-12-28 09:26:52
|
| I haven't seen BBC's Sherlock, but I watched the first 2 episodes of Elementary and don't care if I ever see another one. |
|
|
Comment made by Travis Conner (71.79.58.232 ) on 2012-12-14 16:11:44
|
| I'm not being a homer, but I prefer the IT version per modern versions. I've listened to all the modern BBC versions that I know of. Most of them were ok, but a bit dull.
There's also a contemporary version from Big Finish, but I've never heard it, so I can't rate them.
Per the TV versions, it's a no-brainer. Jeremy Brett is my favorite.
Per all of the extant radio versions that I've heard from 1933 onward, my favorite is Basil Rathbone. |
|
|
Comment made by GrafenwoehrLove (71.52.107.205 ) on 2012-12-04 07:22:21
|
| There is only 1 Sherlock (BRath) & 1 Watson (N Bruce). We need better Stories from IT too. |
|
|
Comment made by MG in Vancouver (71.237.242.206 ) on 2012-11-26 00:12:25
|
| This isn't a votable option, but my write-in preference is Robert Downey Jr. in the new movie franchise. I know it's nothing like the Holmes of the books, but the movies are clever, funny, and thoroughly enjoyable! |
|
|
